[Date Prev][Date Next]   [Thread Prev][Thread Next]   [Thread Index] [Date Index] [Author Index]

Re: [Possibly OT] Trademarks



Jeff Spaleta wrote:
What happens if you want to put in a patch into fedora that upstream
mozilla does not agree with?  If you have to continue to get upstream
approval before every patch is applied, don't you run the risk of
disagreement which will necesitate renaming and replacing the icons?
Isn't this a potential maintence issue for Core?  Disagreements do
happen.  I have no problem with mozilla protecting its marks. But I
would prefer fedora to package mozilla using the iceweazel option and
not use mozilla's marks at all to forestall any abrupt branding change
required over disagreeable patches.

We want to stay as close to upstream as possible. I have been an upstream developer before joining Red Hat, and continue pushing my changes upstream. The icons patches are preparing to be landed upstream (I've sort of let them languish a little because of holidays and RHEL bugs I've been working on).


My thoughts in general on this are basically that one of the reasons we are using "Firefox" is for the brand name recognition. Websites, ISVs, etc. will say they work with Firefox, not Iceweasel, not Epiphany. People complained ON THIS LIST because we were not using "Firefox" at one point. Well, we are now. If we decide to drop "Firefox", it might make more sense to switch back to Epiphany rather than Iceweasel, which fits in stronger with GNOME and the desktop.

I'd like however to work together with the Mozilla Foundation rather than against them. Obviously, they want us as a distributor and we want to distribute their software.


Also please note that in order to even get the "Firefox" name and
artwork built in if you are rolling your own build, you have to
knowingly turn it on with a few environment variables and configure flags.


Are you talking about the upstream source or the fedora srpm here?

Upstream source.



[Date Prev][Date Next]   [Thread Prev][Thread Next]   [Thread Index] [Date Index] [Author Index]