[Date Prev][Date Next]   [Thread Prev][Thread Next]   [Thread Index] [Date Index] [Author Index]

Re: edit root alias when installing the OS



Rahul Sundaram wrote:

On the contrary, graphical tools can make it easy as well as safe by designing and limiting the input as well as providing interactive warnings etc.
   In theory GUIs can be a good thing.

In practice, they suck. It's painful to watch people who use GUIs struggling with interminable menus, file choosers and modal dialog boxes to do simple things that can be done in a few keystrokes in a CLI.

Even companies that are famous for producing products that are "easy to use" make products that are horrible: just try making iTunes stop playing music, or see how many images (1500 or so) it takes to make iPhoto start breaking down. At work I've been working with a commercial CMS that is actually pretty good, but has an astonishing number of "dropped a few bits on the floor" errors because of the complexity of the GUI.

Even my wife is starting to prefer playing music with bash and ogg123 (it's not hard to play all the tracks on an album in order, for instance.)

One big part of the trouble is that there are different orders that people can do things in: the "wizard" strategy of putting a user in a tunnel where they need to make decisions in a particular order and you don't waste their attention with irrelevant choices is one of the best ideas, but you've got to be enable to script out every scenario -- it's a lot of design work. A user-initiative interface might look like a better idea, but the combinatorics of ways users could do things are exponential, making debugging and testing a ball of string that you never get to the end of.

People also have a hard time learning GUI interfaces -- it might not be "politically correct" to say, but why else are there 1500 page tomes on how to use Microsoft Word?

Unix GUIs are particularly plauged by a mismatch between data structures and the things an application wants to do with them. This is the reason why a decent GUI doesn't exist for Apache configuration after all these years: you can't really map the space of Apache configurations to a GUI in a useful way. A "wizard" for common configurations is easy, but a GUI that handles 90% of what beginners want to do and 10% of what experts want to do is close to useless.

To make GUIs work, Unix would have to give up on human-comprehensible configuration files. (Yes, that means XML.) Just the other day I was realizing how hamstrung Firefox is by being based on the open mbox format -- it's not a scalable way of dealing with mailboxes > 500 MB. But that's the road to Opera M2... Storing your mail in a roach motel where you'll never get it out.



[Date Prev][Date Next]   [Thread Prev][Thread Next]   [Thread Index] [Date Index] [Author Index]