Re: sound problems

[Suren Karapetyan <surenkarapetyan gmail com>]

Paulo Cavalcanti wrote:
> On Mon, Jan 5, 2009 at 2:16 PM, Christopher Stone 
> <chris stone gmail com <mailto:chris stone gmail com>> wrote:
>
>     2009/1/4 Paulo Cavalcanti <promac gmail com
>     <mailto:promac gmail com>>:
>     > You can try the latest alsa snapshot available in ATrpms:
>
>     Whoa, bad advice...anyone with half a brain knows to stay well clear
>     of anything coming from ATrpms.  Axel Thimm is one of the the worst
>     packagers in the Fedora community, and installing his packages is
>     *extremely* dangerous.
>
>     Anyway, I have this sound problem too, thanks atleast for pointing me
>     to the bug number...
>
>
> Well, a lot of packages in ATrpms are mine. Including this alsa snapshot.
> I am the person who spent almost two weeks with Takashi trying to debug
> the sigmatel codec. Therefore, I think your comment is directed to me.
Thanks for Your hard work!
But the problem is not just with sigmatel.
It looks like many people with different configurations have problems 
with the new alsa.
I'm sure trying to fix them one by one in F10 is WRONG.
It's already ~10 days sound is broken for many users.
Most of them are not on this list/bugzilla. They just try to play a song 
and hear no sound and say "This fedora thing is bad. I should switch to 
RHEL/CentOS/Ubuntu/MAC/Windows."
Fixing the problems one by one may last for days or weeks or even months.
What guaranties to bring sound back to everyone for whom it worked 10 
days ago is reverting ALSA to previews version.
Then we can switch to ALSA 1.0.18a in rawhide where none will be upset 
to not have sound for a month or two.