Re: 2.6-test10 and ECN

["Nathan G. Grennan" <fedora-list cygnusx-1 org>]

On Tue, 2003-11-25 at 22:19, Barry K. Nathan wrote:
> I'd argue that the /etc/sysctl.conf line is the real "fix", insofar as 
> disabling ECN at all can be considered a "fix" and not a "workaround".
> Then people have the option of editing /etc/sysctl.conf to re-enable
> ECN, without having to recompile the kernel. 
> 

   This could be argued, but the main problem with it is not every
newbie knows about it. Even though I knew about it from the past it took
me a few days to put two and two together. Ideally you could enable ECN
support, but change the default from enabled to disabled.

   As far as I know there isn't even a large gain from it. So if it is a
small gain for a big loss of functionality by default, I say disable by
default.

> (Mandrake has been doing this since one of their 8.x releases, BTW.)
> 

   Another reason not to use Mandrake. The last time I tried them was in
the 8.x series and I found it too buggy.