Re: Digital music volume problem.

[Matt Morgan <matt morgan-fedora-list brooklynmuseum org>]

Thanks! Sounds great.

While I totally, completely want a compressor limiter, I think that will 
have to wait. :-(

On 04/07/2004 02:17 PM, Joel Jaeggli wrote:

> for xmms the volume normalizer plugin can help.
>
> http://www.xmms.org/plugins.php?details=23
>
> on the hardware side... I have a device called a compresser limiter that 
> does essentially the same thing, it's probably a little spendy for just 
> plonking between your sound output and your speakers on random pc's but 
> it's a useful tool for radio-stations, home-theater rigs, and some video 
> conferencing applications (what we got it for).
>
> joelja
>
> On Wed, 7 Apr 2004, Matt Morgan wrote:
>
>  
>
> > The main reason I don't absolutely love digital music is the volume 
> > problem. I ripped everything to ogg vorbis with grip, and the volume of 
> > each song varies so widely that every third song I have to fix the 
> > volume. This is OK on my desktop but it's hard to imagine doing that 
> > with the laptop attached to my home audio system.
> >
> > How do people handle this? Is there ripping software that will look for 
> > the volume peaks and set the volume for each track so the highest peaks 
> > are the same? I realize that wouldn't be perfect--across different 
> > genres of music especially--but maybe there is some smarter way. I have 
> > also heard that doing this can damage the quality of the music, since it 
> > may tend to amplify ambient noise, but I sincerely doubt that would 
> > bother me as much as having to interrupt dinner to change the volume on 
> > the stereo. Apart from grip, I checked Rhythmbox (Sound Juicer?) briefly 
> > and it didn't seem to have any such setting either. But maybe I'm blind.
> >
> > The other way to handle it is in the player, I guess. I have an external 
> > USB SoundBlaster sound card that comes with some software that manages 
> > the volume from track to track, or so it claims. I kind of doubt it does 
> > this dynamically, but rather reads through the tracks and saves metadata 
> > in them that it then reads when playing. The software is Windows-only, 
> > I'm pretty sure, and I haven't tried it yet. Is there some Linux 
> > counterpart?
> >
> > Thanks a lot,
> > Matt
> >
> >
> >
> >    
>
>