[Date Prev][Date Next]   [Thread Prev][Thread Next]   [Thread Index] [Date Index] [Author Index]

Re: Independent Fedora bug tracker

On 04/22/2009 11:57 PM, Tom Lane wrote:
Basil Mohamed Gohar<abu_hurayrah hidayahonline org>  writes:
And now, on to the advantages as I see them:

It would be polite of you to at least acknowledge that there might
be DISadvantages.

The main one from my personal perspective is that I don't need an
extra bug tracker in my daily work.  Right now, Red Hat's bugzilla
is all that I need to look at to handle both RHEL and Fedora
responsibilities.  If there are two trackers involved, one or the
other is going to get looked at less frequently, and given who pays
me I'm afraid Fedora is going to lose out.

Now the above argument means nothing much if you just consider my
personal effort compared to all of Fedora, but when you consider that
it applies to every Red Hat engineer I think it becomes significant.
There are enough Red Hat people involved in Fedora that penalizing
all of us will put a noticeable drag on the project.

			regards, tom lane

Those are some really good points. In the "FOSS needs a central bugtracker" thread, there's an idea of issue trackers communicating with each other. Theoretically, this would alleviate some, if not all, of the work load of someone having to check two issue trackers, because if one can be consider upstream to the other, then the data can flow with the work only needing to be done in one place.

I definitely acknowledge disadvantages, but I am also definitely arguing this from a community standpoint. Having said that, I did not want to minimize what Red Hat contributes to Fedora. And having said *that*, Red Hat will benefit from anything that benefits Fedora. Directly.

I believe a solution exists where Fedora's independence in terms of issue tracking is not a burden on Red Hat's contributors to it. But I don't know that I have the experience to say what that solution is just yet. Hence, this thread for brainstorming. ;)

[Date Prev][Date Next]   [Thread Prev][Thread Next]   [Thread Index] [Date Index] [Author Index]