mpg321 decision needed

Warren Togami warren at togami.com
Fri Jan 9 03:05:55 UTC 2004


https://bugzilla.fedora.us/show_bug.cgi?id=1186
mpg321 proposed Legacy update

Due to licensing issues with anything related to MP3, after some 
discussions it seems that we cannot issue an update for this package. 
It was suggested that Legacy should publish an update notification 
recommending that users stop using it, or even remove the package.  This 
is a certainty.

What we must decide upon is whether we should also issue a mpg321 
package update that removes MP3 functionality.  This is only to force 
the vulnerable program to uninstall from systems.  I personally am in 
favor of this option, but please discuss the pros & cons.

A package update may be necessary because IIRC mpg321 is Required by 
other packages in RH7.x, meaning removing mpg321 may be an infeasible 
suggestion in the update notification.  Please somebody check on this 
and report back.

I personally feel that removing mpg321 or crippling its functionality in 
Legacy is not much of a loss, since the majority of Legacy users are 
servers.  Maybe some businesses use Legacy for workstations, but think 
of a broken MP3 decoder as productivity gain? =)

Warren





More information about the fedora-legacy-list mailing list