[Date Prev][Date Next]   [Thread Prev][Thread Next]   [Thread Index] [Date Index] [Author Index]

Re: OT: Massachusetts Verdict: MS Office Formats Out



Matthew Saltzman wrote:
SNIP
Now you want to save the modified document in .doc or .txt format. oowriter can't tell until it actually carries out the conversion if anything you've done could not be preserved in the external format. (Well, for txt format, it knows for sure that information will be lost, but it can't know if you care.) You might also have created a document from scratch in oowriter, and oowriter would never have had the opportunity to analyse any version in an external format. Your creation would be in OOo format with no possibility of knowing what formatting information might be lost on conversion until the conversion is carried out.

One way to proceed would be to export the document anyway and warn you ex post that formatting information was lost during the conversion. But that doesn't seem to be the convention. The convention seems to be to warn you in advance if the conversion might fail and ask if that's what you want. You could argue that an ex post warning would be better, but you can't argue that oowriter can always know ex ante precisely when the warning is needed.


Perhaps you are right. The only distinction between the crap
MS puts out and OO is that OO is open source crap. :-)

[take that as a very BIG smiley!]

Mike


Now if MS would only warn that it's closed format isn't that transportable across versions of Word. One reason that business my wife works for moved to OOo. To much time wasted re-formatting documents between Mac and Windows Word. At least OOo works the same between Linux, Mac and Windows with only minor differences.

And as my wife said today, OOo files are so much smaller than Word files.

--
Robin Laing


[Date Prev][Date Next]   [Thread Prev][Thread Next]   [Thread Index] [Date Index] [Author Index]