[Bug 523343] Review Request: zikula-module-EZComments - Simple Zikula module that provides comment functions to other modules

Tue Nov 3 04:47:07 UTC 2009

Please do not reply directly to this email. All additional
comments should be made in the comments box of this bug.

https://bugzilla.redhat.com/show_bug.cgi?id=523343

--- Comment #13 from Jon Stanley <jonstanley at gmail.com>  2009-11-02 23:47:06 EDT ---
OK, we've seen many and varied md5sums of the upstream zip file.  For the
record, the zikula.md5sum file was generated by doing a 'find . -type f | xargs
md5sum > zikula.md5sum', and the results compared with a upstream downloaded
copy.  The results are provided below:

[jstanley at rugrat 1]$ find . | md5sum -c /home/jstanley/zikula.md5sum 
./modules/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnmigrateapi/news.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnmigrateapi/pnProfile.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnmigrateapi/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnmigrateapi/polls.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnmigrateapi/pnComments.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnmigrateapi/pnFlashGames.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnmigrateapi/dummy.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnmigrateapi/reviews.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnblocks/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnblocks/ezcomments.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnuser.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pndocs/credits.txt: OK
./modules/EZComments/pndocs/todo.txt: OK
./modules/EZComments/pndocs/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pndocs/install.txt: OK
./modules/EZComments/pndocs/license.txt: OK
./modules/EZComments/pndocs/changelog.txt: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnstyle/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnstyle/style.css: OK
./modules/EZComments/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnmyprofileapi.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntables.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnsearchapi.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pninit.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnlang/spa/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnlang/fra/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnlang/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnlang/ces/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnlang/nor/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnlang/ita/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnlang/nld/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnlang/eng/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnlang/eng/template_Standard.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnlang/eng/common.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnlang/deu/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnaccountapi.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnincludes/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnincludes/ezcomments_admin_modifyhandler.class.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnincludes/ezcomments_user_modifyhandler.class.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnincludes/ezcomments_admin_modifyconfighandler.class.php:
OK
./modules/EZComments/pnincludes/common.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/fra/sendpm.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/fra/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/fra/go_up.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/fra/go_down.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/fra/profile.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/yellow.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/nld/sendpm.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/nld/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/nld/go_up.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/nld/go_down.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/nld/profile.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/green.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/comment.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/red.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/admin.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/eng/sendpm.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/eng/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/eng/go_up.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/eng/go_down.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/eng/profile.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/deu/sendpm.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/deu/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/deu/go_up.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/deu/go_down.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/deu/profile.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnimages/mycommentsbutton.gif: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnversion.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnuserapi.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnadminapi.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnjavascript/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnjavascript/toggle.js: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_myprofile_tab.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_admin_delete.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_admin_stats.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/plugins/modifier.commentstatus.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/plugins/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/plugins/modifier.formatezcomment.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/plugins/modifier.issued.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/plugins/modifier.modified.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/plugins/function.ezcommentsstylesheet.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/plugins/function.ezcommentsimg.php: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_mail_newcomment.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_admin_modulestats.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/Standard/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/Standard/ezcomments_user_view.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/Standard/style.css: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_admin_deleteitem.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/index.html: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_admin_applyrules_results.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_block_ezcomments.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_admin_menu.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_user_header.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_admin_purge.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_search_form.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_admin_cleanup.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_admin_modify.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_user_atom.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_user_main.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_admin_modifyconfig.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_block_ezcomments_modify.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_mail_modcomment.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_user_modify.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_user_rss.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_admin_migrate.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_admin_applyrules_form.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_admin_deletemodule.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pntemplates/ezcomments_admin_view.htm: OK
./modules/EZComments/pnadmin.php: OK
./module_EZComments_1-61.zip: FAILED
md5sum: WARNING: 1 of 112 computed checksums did NOT match

At this point, I'm confident saying that the source is genuine, even if they do
a *really* poor job of release management.

This is a simple package and follows all applicable guidelines.

APPROVED.

Please put a link to this bug in the imported package, and note the exception
granted to upstream md5sum matching, since all of the individual files appear
to match.

-- 
Configure bugmail: https://bugzilla.redhat.com/userprefs.cgi?tab=email
------- You are receiving this mail because: -------
You are on the CC list for the bug.