[Date Prev][Date Next]   [Thread Prev][Thread Next]   [Thread Index] [Date Index] [Author Index]

[Linux-cluster] Re: GFS



Hi Zach,

Zach Brown writes:
I'll try, briefly.

Thanks for the excellent explanation.


Zach Brown writes:
And that's the problem. Because they're acquired in ->nopage they can
be acquired during a fault that is servicing the 'buf' argument to an
outer file->{read,write} operation which has grabbed a lock for the
target file. Acquiring multiple locks introduces the risk of ABBA
deadlocks. It's trivial to construct examples of mmap(), read(), and
write() on 2 nodes with 2 files that deadlock.

But couldn't we use make_pages_present() to figure which locks we need, sort them, and then grab them?


Zach Brown writes:
I brought this up with some people at the kernel summit but no one,
including myself, considers it a high priority.  It wouldn't be too hard
to construct a patch if people want to take a look.

I guess it's not a problem as long as the kernel has zero or one cluster filesystems that support mmap(). After we have two or more, we have a problem.


The GFS2 vma walk needs fixing anyway, I think, as it can lead to buffer overflow (if we have more locks during the second walk).

Pekka


[Date Prev][Date Next]   [Thread Prev][Thread Next]   [Thread Index] [Date Index] [Author Index]